“Not without its faults” Ghost in the Shell review

Ghost in the Shell review: by Adam Brannon

UK certification: 12A

14859347_1040969846011519_1192281544_o-copyTurning the beloved Ghost in the Shell manga franchise into a Hollywood film that’ll please picky Western audiences was always going to be a tough job for director Rupert Sanders (Snow White & the Huntsman).

Casting the central lead, The Major, proved even more difficult. When Scarlett Johansson’s name was attached to play the role, Hollywood was once again accused of white-washing, a tag lobbied at Gods of Egypt last year. The finished product is now in cinemas around the globe, but is it the disaster many predicted?

In the near future, Major (Scarlett Johansson) is the first of her kind: a human who has been cyber-enhanced to create a perfect soldier devoted to stopping the world’s most dangerous criminals. When terrorism reaches a new level that includes the ability to hack into people’s minds and control them, Major is uniquely qualified to stop it. As she prepares to face a new enemy, Major finds truths about her past that changes her view on the world forever.

The greatest accolade that can be given to Ghost in the Shell is that its pre-release detractors haven’t stopped people from going to see it. The cinema was busy on its opening night, with many itching to see how such a universally loved manga could be fine-tuned for a Western palate.


Photo by Paramount Pictures.

Visually; the film is absolutely stunning and is best viewed on the biggest screen possible. Each frame is dripping with detail and the naturally heavy use of CGI doesn’t detract from creating a vibrant metropolis that feels every bit alive.

The story is simple to follow and easy to enjoy. It’s exciting, emotional and boosted by a fine, if slightly uninspiring performance from Johansson. The rest of the cast can also be described as fine, with only Juliette Binoche’s mother-like Dr. Ouélet creating any sort of lasting impact.

And this is Ghost in the Shell’s fundamental weakness. Outside of Binoche, the rest of the cast are largely forgettable and that’s a real shame considering the characters in its excellent source material were, for want of a better word, magical. Even the villain is devoid any sort of tyranny.

Thankfully though, the impressive set design and well-choreographed action sequences mask the disappointing array of characters well and steamroll this thrilling adventure to a very satisfying conclusion. It’s also accompanied by a gorgeous soundtrack by Clint Mansell and Lorne Balfe that compliments the futuristic nature of the film beautifully.

Sitting in the theatre, it felt at times like I was watching an updated version of Total Recall, and that’s no bad thing. Comparing it to a cult classic is probably what director Rupert Sanders was trying to achieve and despite its poor characters, Ghost in the Shell has every opportunity to succeed as a film we look back on in 30 years and think “hey, that’s actually pretty good”.

Overall, Ghost in the Shell is one hell of a good-looking film. Couple this with impressive special effects and a rollercoaster ride of a story and you have a big screen experience that’s great for 106 minutes, but probably won’t have any lasting impact once the end credits roll.

Budget: $110million/Music: Clint Mansell, Lorne Balfe/Length: 106minutes

:star: :star: :star: :star:

Rob’s Thoughts

14886217_1040838869357950_851251975_nGhost in the Shell is a film that I didn’t think I’d like as much as I do, if I’m perfectly honest. Hollywood picking up a weird, hard-R rated sci-fi cult classic from the 80’s or 90’s brought us Robocop, The Thing and Total Recall, some of the worst movies of the 2010’s.

But the original is a film where phenomenal visuals and great action set-pieces is plagued by a boring, slow and rubbish plot and philosophy lectures, so dumbing it down is, for once, an improvement.

And yes, it is a little too on the nose at times (“The Major’s called Mary Kelley, it’s like Frankenstein, geddit, we’re clever!”) but it’s carried forward by a great central performance of a fantastically realised protagonist, a well-paced if extremely predictable plot, and well-shot action, while keeping all of the excellent visuals that made the original worth remaking in the first place. Take note, Hollywood; this is how a remake should be done.


2 thoughts on ““Not without its faults” Ghost in the Shell review

  1. Pingback: MM Top 5: Anime Films | Movie Metropolis UK

  2. Pingback: MM Top 5: Things Marvel needs to stop | Movie Metropolis UK

Leave a Reply